Skip to content
SPM Tuition
Physics · Electromagnetism

Comparing motors and generators

Motors and generators both have a coil and a magnet, so you swap their parts in answers.

A motor and a generator are the same arrangement used in opposite directions. A motor turns electrical energy into motion, and a generator turns motion into electrical energy.

This lesson is part of SPM Physics electromagnetism. It uses the force rule from determining magnetic-force direction and induction from explaining electromagnetic induction.

How do they compare?

D.c. motor A.c. generator
Energy change electrical to kinetic kinetic to electrical
Principle force on a current in a magnetic field induced e.m.f. from changing flux
Input current from a supply rotation of the coil
Output rotation alternating e.m.f.
Contact parts split-ring commutator two slip rings
Direction rule Fleming’s left-hand rule Lenz’s law, or the right-hand rule your course uses

Worked explanation: why the commutator?

In a coil in a field, the force on one side is up and on the other side is down. The coil turns until its plane is at right angles to the field.

If the current stayed in the same direction, each side would be pushed back after passing that position, and the coil would stop. The commutator reverses the coil’s connections at that moment. The force on each side therefore still turns the coil the same way.

Worked explanation: what slip rings allow

A generator coil turns through the field, and the e.m.f. changes direction every half turn. Slip rings keep each end of the coil connected to its own brush.

The external circuit therefore sees current that alternates. Replacing them with a commutator would flip the connection at each half turn and give a one-direction, pulsing output.

The mistake that loses marks

A common slip is to write “a generator uses a commutator to produce a.c.”, which swaps the parts.

The fix is to tie the part to the aim. A motor needs continuous rotation, so it uses a commutator. An a.c. generator needs a continuous connection, so it uses slip rings.

Check yourself

A generator’s coil is rotated twice as fast. State what happens to the size and frequency of the output, with a reason.

Answer

The flux changes twice as fast, so the peak e.m.f. doubles. The coil completes twice as many turns each second, so the frequency also doubles.

Both follow from the rate of change of flux and the rotation rate.

What to study next

Go on to calculating transformer relationships, then test the machines in the practice set.

Use the mistake log to track where parts are swapped. For a teacher to go through the diagrams with you, see online one-to-one Physics tuition or the one-hour trial class (from RM50).

Common questions

What is the main difference between a motor and a generator?

A motor converts electrical energy to kinetic energy using the force on a current in a magnetic field. A generator converts kinetic energy to electrical energy using induction. They are built from the same kinds of parts used in opposite ways.

What does the commutator do in a d.c. motor?

It is a split ring that reverses the current in the coil every half turn. This keeps the force on each side of the coil in the same turning direction, so the coil keeps rotating instead of rocking back and forth.

Why does an a.c. generator use slip rings?

Slip rings keep each end of the coil connected to the same external contact through the turn. The output therefore alternates in direction each half turn. A commutator would turn it into a pulsing direct current.

How do I make the generator output larger?

Rotate the coil faster, use a stronger magnet, add more turns or use a larger coil. A larger e.m.f. means a faster rate of change of flux. Faster rotation also raises the frequency of the output.

In one-to-one lessons a teacher can ask you to explain each part aloud and hear straight away where you swap the commutator and slip rings, or force and induction.

  • Online one-to-one lessons for your child with an experienced teacher.
  • Your first class is a one-hour trial, from RM50. The fee is agreed before you book.
  • Happy with the teacher? Continue with lessons of about 1.5 hours. If not, ask for another teacher.