Skip to content
SPM Tuition
Biology · Cellular respiration

Comparing aerobic and anaerobic respiration

You know both terms, but the products and the energy amounts keep getting mixed up.

Aerobic respiration uses oxygen to break glucose down fully and releases a large amount of energy. Anaerobic respiration works without oxygen and releases less energy, leaving lactic acid or ethanol.

This lesson opens the SPM Biology cellular respiration chapter. The next lesson looks at substrates, products and energy in more detail.

What are the word equations?

Aerobic respiration: glucose + oxygen → carbon dioxide + water + energy.

Anaerobic respiration in muscle: glucose → lactic acid + energy.

Anaerobic respiration in yeast: glucose → ethanol + carbon dioxide + energy.

Worked example: a sprint and a loaf of bread

Two situations use the same idea. In the first, a student sprints 100 metres. In the second, yeast is mixed into dough.

Aerobic (jogging muscle) Anaerobic (sprinting muscle) Anaerobic (yeast in dough)
Oxygen needed Yes No No
Substrate Glucose Glucose Glucose
Products Carbon dioxide and water Lactic acid Ethanol and carbon dioxide
Energy released Large amount Small amount Small amount
Where it happens Cytoplasm, then mitochondria Cytoplasm Cytoplasm

The sprinting muscle builds up lactic acid, which is why the legs feel tired. The yeast releases carbon dioxide, which makes the dough rise.

The mistake that costs marks

The common slip is to write that anaerobic respiration releases no energy. It does release energy, only a smaller amount, because the glucose is broken down only partly.

Wrong Right
Energy without oxygen None Less, because glucose is partly broken down
Muscle product Ethanol Lactic acid
Yeast product Lactic acid Ethanol and carbon dioxide

Students also mix up the two anaerobic routes. Link each product to its organism before the exam: muscle with lactic acid, yeast with ethanol.

How should you write a comparison answer?

Give one point for each side in the same sentence. For example: “Aerobic respiration needs oxygen, but anaerobic respiration does not.”

A comparison with only one side, such as “aerobic respiration needs oxygen”, earns less than one that names both.

Check yourself

A baker notices that a dough with yeast rises slowly in a cold room. State the products of the yeast’s respiration and say which one makes the dough rise.

Answer

Yeast respires anaerobically on the sugars in the dough. The products are ethanol and carbon dioxide, and energy is released.

The carbon dioxide forms gas bubbles that make the dough rise.

What to study next

Continue with relating substrates, products and energy. The biological data interpretation trainer helps you practise reading results from investigations, and the mistake log and paper-error review records slips.

If you would like a teacher to check your comparison sentences, see online one-to-one Biology tuition.

Common questions

What is the main difference between aerobic and anaerobic respiration?

Aerobic respiration needs oxygen and breaks glucose down completely, releasing a large amount of energy. Anaerobic respiration does not use oxygen and releases a smaller amount of energy, with lactic acid or ethanol as products.

What are the products of anaerobic respiration?

In muscle cells the product is lactic acid. In yeast the products are ethanol and carbon dioxide. Both release energy, but less than aerobic respiration.

Where does respiration happen in a cell?

Glucose is first broken down in the cytoplasm. The later stages of aerobic respiration take place in the mitochondria. Anaerobic respiration stays in the cytoplasm.

Why does bread dough rise?

Yeast respire anaerobically on the sugars in the dough and release carbon dioxide gas. The gas forms bubbles that make the dough expand.

If you can recite both equations but lose marks on comparison questions, a one-to-one Biology teacher can rehearse the comparison sentences with you until each one names both sides.

  • Online one-to-one lessons for your child with an experienced teacher.
  • Your first class is a one-hour trial, from RM50. The fee is agreed before you book.
  • Happy with the teacher? Continue with lessons of about 1.5 hours. If not, ask for another teacher.